
- 1 Key Takeaways
- 2 What “Having Scale” Really Means in Aquaculture
- 3 The Underlying Problem: Industry Demands What Small Producers Cannot Offer Alone
- 4 Cooperatives, Associations, and Clusters: How Small Producers Sell Together
- 5 The Tocantins Experience: From Isolation to Supplying Institutional Markets
- 6 What a Small- or Medium-Scale Fish Farmer Can Do Today
- 7 Returning to the Starting Point
- 8 Entradas relacionadas:
Key Takeaways
- Without production scale, most formal buyers (aquaculture processors, supermarkets, and public procurement programs) cannot independently source from a small-scale aquaculture producer.
- Achieving scale also requires standardized quality, consistent deliveries, and coordination with the rest of the value chain.
- Cooperatives, associations, consortia, and clusters enable multiple small-scale aquaculture producers to operate commercially as a single large enterprise.
- Shared costs (transportation, storage, and marketing), greater bargaining power, and access to technology, certifications, and technical assistance.
- In Tocantins (Brazil), a technical network coordinated by Embrapa and Conab enabled local fish farmers to access previously unreachable institutional markets.
The harvest went well. The fish reached an excellent size, water parameters remained stable throughout the cycle, and mortality was low. However, when the fish farmer goes out looking for a buyer, the picture changes. The regional processing plant politely explains that it cannot take their harvest: it requires several tons per week, uninterruptedly, of uniform size and under a single quality standard. Meanwhile, a public food procurement program demands formal documentation, processing infrastructure the farmer does not own, and a volume they cannot reach alone. In the end, they end up selling to the same middleman as always, at whatever price the middleman decides.
Anyone who has worked in small- or medium-scale fish farming recognizes this scene. The problem is not in the pond; it is in the size.
That is the central thesis of a recent document from Embrapa Pesca e Aquicultura—the aquaculture research center of the Brazilian Agricultural Research Corporation—published in 2026 as part of its Diálogos Estratégicos series. Its authors, Renata Melon Barroso Bertolini and Diego Neves de Sousa, argue that production scale is a determining factor in accessing formal and more profitable aquaculture markets. They also point out that the most viable path for small- and medium-scale producers is not to grow in isolation, but to organize collectively. For those currently selling cheap due to a lack of volume, the message is direct: the door to better prices does not always open with more ponds of your own, but with better alliances.
What “Having Scale” Really Means in Aquaculture
For years, the debate over competitiveness in aquaculture revolved almost exclusively around technical aspects: better feed, better genetics, and more efficient health management. All of that remains fundamental. However, Embrapa researchers highlight a reality that many producers experience daily, yet is rarely analyzed with the same rigor: even if you produce well, if your volume is low and irregular, the highest-paying markets remain out of reach.
The document describes scale as a sequence of interconnected effects, much like a recirculating system where each stage feeds into the next. Maximizing production increases volume; this optimizes the use of resources, machinery, and equipment, reducing the cost per kilogram produced. Lower costs expand profit margins, and a larger supply provides greater bargaining power to access more profitable markets.
The authors summarize the main benefits into three pillars:
- Economies of scale: Spreading fixed costs across more kilograms of fish reduces the unit cost. It follows the same logic as an aerator: it costs nearly the same to run it in a pond at half capacity as in one that is fully utilized.
- More favorable commercial terms: Producers who can guarantee consistent volume secure long-term partnerships and more competitive prices.
- Greater bargaining power: Both with input suppliers (feed, fingerlings, and equipment) and with buyers of the final product.
Nevertheless, the document insists on a crucial nuance: having scale is not just about volume. It requires aligning quality standards, ensuring supply regularity, and integrating the different links in the production chain. An industrial buyer is not merely looking for large tonnages; they need the certainty that next week, and the week after, they will receive a homogeneous product. Predictability is worth just as much as quantity, especially in a sector exposed to price fluctuations, seasonality, and environmental risks.
The Underlying Problem: Industry Demands What Small Producers Cannot Offer Alone
Here lies the crux of the matter. The fish processing industry demands scale and predictability, as its contracts, logistics, and margins depend on them. An isolated producer, no matter how well they manage their ponds, can rarely guarantee both conditions simultaneously. Meanwhile, the apparent solution—growing individually—requires capital, infrastructure, and a level of risk that most small- and medium-scale fish farmers cannot assume.
It is at this point that the researchers propose shifting the mindset. Instead of asking, “How do I grow?”, the question becomes, “How do we grow together?” According to the document, the horizontal organization of the primary sector—that is, the union of producers operating at the same link in the chain—forms the foundation for meeting industry demands. By doing so, they manage to expand margins, sign stable contracts, and consolidate commercial advantages.
Mantente siempre informado
Stay Informed
Únete a nuestras comunidades para recibir al instante las noticias, informes y análisis más importantes del sector acuícola.
Join our communities to get instant access to the most important news, reports, and analysis from the aquaculture industry.
Cooperatives, Associations, and Clusters: How Small Producers Sell Together
The models proposed by the authors are well known in the agricultural sector: cooperatives, associations, consortia, and clusters—also referred to as local productive arrangements or hubs. What defines the latter is that they bring together companies, cooperatives, and other organizations within a defined territory to act in a coordinated manner and boost competitiveness.
According to the document, organizing under these frameworks enables small- and medium-scale producers to:
- Exchange experiences.
- Standardize production and stabilize supply.
- Gain scale and competitiveness.
- Professionalize management.
- Access certifications, quality seals, and technical assistance services.
The authors also highlight a key concept: “scale composition.” The idea is simple and powerful. Each fish farmer within a productive arrangement can remain small or medium-sized, yet the sum of all of them generates a collective capacity to compete in markets that demand large volumes, including exports. It works like a network of small ponds connected to a single outlet channel: none of them can fill the truck alone; together, they fill it every week.
This scale composition offers concrete advantages:
- Shared costs: Warehouses, transportation, marketing, and other infrastructure can be used jointly, allowing small producers to access resources and technologies that would be unfeasible on their own.
- Access to technology and innovation: Operating within a shared ecosystem makes it easier to exchange technological improvements, best practices, and processes, resulting in greater efficiency.
- Greater production capacity: Combined volume makes it possible to meet large demands and negotiate better prices with input suppliers.
- Diversification: Knowledge sharing and group flexibility drive new products and faster adaptation to market demands.
None of this happens automatically, and the document does not present it as a magic formula. The authors warn that the process requires efficient coordination, technological investment, and governance that ensures predictability. In practice, a poorly managed cooperative can create more conflicts than solutions. Collective organization works when there are clear rules, leadership, and a commitment from all members to the agreed-upon standards.
The Tocantins Experience: From Isolation to Supplying Institutional Markets
To demonstrate that the proposal is not merely theoretical, the document highlights a concrete case in the Brazilian state of Tocantins. There, Embrapa and the National Supply Company (Companhia Nacional de Abastecimento, Conab) coordinated with other institutions in the fish farming value chain to create a technical network that enabled local producers to sell to institutional markets—namely, public food procurement programs.
The starting point was complex. Prior to this coordination, fish farmers lacked political incentives, basic processing infrastructure, and technical guidance to access public food policies and leverage them in practice. The market existed, but it remained inaccessible.
The strategies implemented succeeded in opening viable alternatives for marketing aquaculture production, turning this experience into a benchmark for other regions facing similar challenges. The case is documented in detail in a study by Sousa et al., published in 2019 in the journal Cadernos de Ciência & Tecnologia, focusing on marketing strategies for fish from family farming for school feeding programs.
The most relevant takeaway from the case is that the solution did not depend on a single piece. It required cooperation among producers, research and extension institutions, government agencies, and other stakeholders. That is perhaps the most valuable lesson: market access rarely depends solely on the producer, yet it never materializes if the producer waits for others to solve it for them.
What a Small- or Medium-Scale Fish Farmer Can Do Today
The Embrapa document offers strategic reflection rather than a step-by-step manual; however, its approach raises key questions that any producer can ask themselves:
- Are there other fish farmers in my area cultivating the same species with a similar level of management?
- Is there already an association or cooperative I can join, or would it be necessary to create one?
- Which regional buyers are not purchasing my production today due to a lack of volume or consistency, and what quantities would they need?
- Which costs could I share with other producers: transportation, ice, storage, processing, or technical assistance?
- Which public, research, or extension institutions could help coordinate this network?
Answering these questions does not guarantee success, but it shifts the perspective: the producer stops focusing solely on the pond and begins to look at the entire value chain.
Returning to the Starting Point
Let us return to the fish farmer from the beginning—the one with an excellent harvest and no one to sell it to at a fair price. According to the approach of the researchers at Embrapa Pesca e Aquicultura, their problem is not solved by producing better, as they already produce well. It is solved when their harvest stops being an isolated offering and becomes part of a larger, standardized, and predictable volume built alongside their neighbors.
In that scenario, the phone call to the processing plant has a different outcome. It is no longer a single producer asking them to accept a few kilograms, but a group offering tons per week of homogeneous quality. And on the other end of the line, for the first time, someone has compelling reasons to listen.
Reference (open access)
Bertolini, R. M. B., & Sousa, D. N. de. (2026). Escala de produção como fator determinante para o acesso a mercados aquícolas (Diálogos Estratégicos). Embrapa Pesca e Aquicultura. 3 p.
Editor at the digital magazine AquaHoy. He holds a degree in Aquaculture Biology from the National University of Santa (UNS) and a Master’s degree in Science and Innovation Management from the Polytechnic University of Valencia, with postgraduate diplomas in Business Innovation and Innovation Management. He possesses extensive experience in the aquaculture and fisheries sector, having led the Fisheries Innovation Unit of the National Program for Innovation in Fisheries and Aquaculture (PNIPA). He has served as a senior consultant in technology watch, an innovation project formulator and advisor, and a lecturer at UNS. He is a member of the Peruvian College of Biologists and was recognized by the World Aquaculture Society (WAS) in 2016 for his contribution to aquaculture.





